Review #1:
For the painting that started Francis Bacon’s career, Painting fails to impress. Not only is his macabre surrealist style pretentious, but he is also incompetent as a painter. Bacon’s brushstrokes are incredibly sloppy, making the painting seem more like a doodle than an actual work of art. He also has no interesting patterns or symmetries in the painting, which makes the piece lack the focus that it desperately needs. This lack of focus bleeds onto the color palette as well. His muted blacks and his gaudy pinks contrast in the worst way possible, and the very miniscule amount of other colors don’t make the painting any less of an eyesore. Bacon’s style, while unique, is actually quite ridiculous. Although he has a lot of horrific images in the painting, Bacon takes away all the emotion from these images by adding silly details that don’t really make sense. How can one take a corpse with an umbrella directly above what’s left of his head seriously, let alone call it art? It’s images like this that make the painting seem amateurish, as well as extremely ostentatious. Of course it’s not supposed to make complete sense due to its surrealist nature, but its abstractions just aren’t interesting enough for us to care. With no real artistic value and an annoying style, Painting demonstrates that Bacon may not be as great or as important as art history leads us to believe. More importantly, Painting shows us that Bacon can be as lazy with his art as he is with his titles.
Review #2:
With Painting’s macabre surrealism, it is easy to see why David Lynch said that he wants Francis Bacon to be his best friend. Historically speaking, Bacon pretty much was the Lynch of his time. Not because they were both “weird” or “dark”, but because they both transported you to worlds that no one really had seen before. In Painting, Bacon creates this otherworldly vibe through intricate details, beautiful surrealism, and a morbid yet passionate style. At first glance, the painting may seem crude and unrefined. The brushstrokes are sporadic and the color scheme wears on your eyes. However, it is this coarseness that makes Painting unique, for it makes the painting seem like it was made in a fit of creative passion where being emotionally honest was just as important as the technical aspects of the piece. Not to say that the details are overlooked. In fact, the details in Painting are what make it interesting. Every element, from the green and red rug to the hanging meat sculpture, helps take you into Bacon’s world where everything feels as real as it is fantastic. And it is fantastic. With such insane imagery as a half decapitated corpse with meat, bones, and an umbrella surrounding it, Painting seems straight out of Salvador Dali’s nightmares. This nightmarish aspect of Painting may disappoint or frighten some, yet it is one of the many aspects that make Bacon’s work special. Through exploring such dark imagery, Painting makes surrealism personal and human instead of just a concept. While Lynch may have taken his place as the art world’s weirdo, Bacon’s Painting proves that his work will live on for years to come.